I found it too long and slow. The two star that I gave is for Bradley Cooper. His acting was amazing as always. Lady Gaga was annoying and irritating (as usual). She was overacting in many scenes. They could've cast a new fresh actor instead of her. She is already a celebrity...and it was obvious in her acting too.

very slow at times, singing hard to understand the words of the songs, don't think any song will be a hit of the movie like the way we were was of the Barbara Streisand version of this movie overall rating fair not as spectacular as the previous 2 versions of this movie

It was fairly boring and predictable. But the music was pretty good.

no chemistry evident between Bradley Cooper and Lady Gaga. He looked grimy throughout the film. Plot moved very slowly. Could have been edited to be shorter.